The Reviews Desk

Every curd we've put on a kitchen scale.

Independent reviews of every cheese curd brand we can get our hands on — mail-order, grocery, regional, fancy, weird. Scored on squeak, texture, salt balance, and shelf life. No affiliate-driven ranking.

The Full Index

Every curd we've tested, scored.

3 roundups · 10 reviews
9.3Score
Gardner's cheese curds packed with cold-pack insulation for mail order
Roundup · 3 producers

The best mail-order cheese curds.

Renard's, Gardner's, and Ellsworth tested on squeak, shipping, and value.

9.2Score
St-Albert poutine with fries, gravy, and cheese curds
Roundup · Poutine

The best curds for poutine.

Tested in gravy: which curds hold shape and melt right under hot gravy.

9.4Score
The best flavored cheese curds, tested and ranked
Roundup · Flavored

The best flavored cheese curds.

Garlic & dill, maple bacon, ghost pepper and more, ranked by how well the flavor works.

9.4Score
Gardner's Garlic & Dill cheese curds
Single brand · Gardner's

Gardner's Garlic & Dill, reviewed.

Our highest-scoring flavored curd. Fresh dill at vat stage, roasted garlic, intact squeak.

9.3Score
Renard's Door County yellow cheese curds
Single brand · Renard's

Renard's Yellow, reviewed.

Award-winning Door County curds. Our top plain pick, best-in-class squeak.

9.1Score
Gardner's plain squeaky cheese curds
Single brand · Gardner's

Gardner's Plain, reviewed.

Top-tier squeak, the most reliable shipping, the everyday value pick.

9.0Score
Ellsworth natural white cheddar cheese curds
Single brand · Ellsworth

Ellsworth Natural, reviewed.

The most available great curd in America, with a 9-month shelf life.

9.0Score
Gardner's maple bacon cheese curds
Single brand · Gardner's

Gardner's Maple Bacon, reviewed.

The best sweet-savory curd we've tested. Restrained maple, smoky backbone.

8.9Score
Gardner's sour cream and onion cheese curds
Single brand · Gardner's

Gardner's Sour Cream & Onion, reviewed.

Chips-and-dip nostalgia in curd form. A limited-edition snacking pick.

9.2Score
Beecher's plain cheese curds
Single brand · Beecher's

Beecher's Plain Cheese Curds, reviewed.

2025 ACS 1st Place. Four-ingredient label. Pike Place Market.

8.5Score
Wisconsin Cheese Co. Hickory Hollow smoked cheese curds
Single brand · Wisconsin Cheese Co.

Hickory Hollow Smoked, reviewed.

Top pick for smoked curds. Real hickory cold-smoke. National via Amazon.

8.7Score
Yancey's Fancy roasted garlic cheese curds
Single brand · Yancey's Fancy

Yancey's Roasted Garlic, reviewed.

New York's House of Flavor. Yellow cheddar base. rBST-free milk.

8.7Score
Henning's garlic and dill cheese curds
Single brand · Henning's

Henning's Garlic & Dill, reviewed.

110-year-old Kiel plant. Master Cheesemaker. Best value in the category.