The Cheesemakers

Every cheesemaker we follow.

From four-generation Wisconsin cooperatives to one-person operations in the Pacific Northwest — the producers we trust, profiled.

12
Brands profiled
7
States & provinces
112
Years (oldest)
1
Person (smallest)
A–Z

Featured brands, alphabetical.

Seattle, WA · Est. 2003

Beecher's Handmade Cheese

The West Coast outlier that takes itself seriously. Flagship curd is the standout.

Read profile →
Wilson, WI · Est. 1996

Cady Cheese

The gas-station surprise that earned a spot in our regular rotation.

Read profile →
Ellsworth, WI · Est. 1910

Ellsworth Co-op

The original "Cheese Curd Capital." 116 years of unmatched salt balance.

Read profile →
Sheboygan, WI · Est. 1948

Gardner's Wisconsin

Tight squeak, clean salt, the most consistent we test. The widest flavored lineup in the category.

Read profile →
Kiel, WI · Est. 1914

Henning's Cheese

Four generations, one building. The most widely available high-quality curd.

Read profile →
Mosinee, WI · Est. 1970

Mullins Cheese

Wisconsin's largest family-owned cheese factory. 5 generations, 500 farms, Ghost Chili Gouda.

Read profile →
Marshfield, WI · Est. 1885

Nasonville Dairy

140 years. 4 Master Cheesemakers. 10 curd varieties. The flavored-curd lab nobody knows about.

Read profile →
Newton, WI · Est. 1963

Pine River Dairy

Specialty curd house with a deep flavored catalog. Not all hits, but the hits are big.

Read profile →
Sturgeon Bay, WI · Est. 1961

Renard's

The publication's top pick. No marketing, no social, fourteen-hour squeak.

Read profile →
Saint-Albert, ON · Est. 1894

St-Albert Fromagerie

Ontario co-op that's been making curds since 1894. Built for poutine.

Read profile →
Theresa, WI · Est. 1922

Widmer's Cheese Cellars

Third-generation brick-cheese specialists who also turn out a quiet, excellent curd.

Read profile →
Pembroke, NY · Est. 1965

Yancey's Fancy

The New York entry. A deep flavored-curd catalog; doesn't match the Wisconsin top tier.

Read profile →